Vusimuzi “Cat” Matlala was moved between prisons in unescorted VW Polos, an Idac investigator told the Madlanga commission on Thursday.

TimesLIVE, EWN and IOL all reported the testimony of Anthony Sehas, an investigator with the Investigating Directorate Against Corruption (Idac). According to EWN, the cars were standard vehicles that were not bulletproof, and the trip ran from Ebongweni Correctional Centre in KwaZulu-Natal to Kgosi Mampuru Correctional Facility in Pretoria. IOL reported that no police or Correctional Services escort travelled with the group and that three vehicles were used. The same report said Matlala wore handcuffs and leg irons throughout the journey, which it put at under six hours. EWN said the distance covered was more than 700 kilometres.

What the commissioners asked

TimesLIVE reported that commissioner Sesi Baloyi asked whether it was standard practice to move a high-profile suspect without backup. “It was my first time [doing it] in this manner, commissioner,” Sehas answered, and said such suspects are normally transported once they are out on bail.

Commissioner Sandile Khumalo asked whether the car was a Polo and whether there was no task force or security. Sehas agreed on both counts, according to TimesLIVE, and said Matlala was cuffed at the wrists and ankles. Khumalo said a Polo is “not the sort of ideal vehicle” for such prisoners, and Sehas agreed.

Commission chairperson Mbuyiseli Madlanga asked whether it made sense to fetch Matlala that way. “We are also military-trained members, and we are armed,” Sehas replied, EWN reported. TimesLIVE said Sehas agreed the way Matlala was transported was “terribly wrong”.

Who gave the instruction

The reports differ on who asked Sehas to take part. TimesLIVE said senior investigator Brian Padayachee asked him to help. IOL reported that Dylan Perumal, described as his superior, told him to collect Matlala and to prepare a travelling memorandum for the move, and that Sehas said he did not know why the memorandum was needed. The accounts are given here as each outlet reported them, and neither is treated as settled. None of the three reports carries a response from Perumal or Idac.

Background

EWN described Matlala as an alleged crime boss. It said the corruption allegations against him relate to a R360 million tender linked to Medicare24, his company.

The commission’s hearings continue. IOL, which carried the testimony as a live report, said the proceedings were still under way when it published, so further evidence from Sehas or other witnesses may add to or change this account.

Earlier evidence: Madlanga commission JMPD bribe evidence from a new witness and the NICOC chief on infiltration.