NERSA has told the Pretoria High Court that its 2025/26 tariff approvals for five councils were unlawful, Daily Maverick and EWN reported.
The five are Johannesburg, Ekurhuleni, Nelson Mandela Bay, Emfuleni and Madibeng. According to court papers quoted by Daily Maverick on 12 November 2026, the approvals “are reviewable, unlawful and invalid, and fall to be set aside”. The Citizen, republishing Moneyweb, reported that the councils’ applications carried errors in their figures, which NERSA did not check before it approved them.
What the court heard
The case is before the High Court in Pretoria. Industrial users brought it. They include Coega Steels, Mpact and a manufacturing cluster of foundries and machinists. Moneyweb reported that the court heard on 9 November that Nelson Mandela Bay businesses were billed 76% above the metro’s cost of supply for 2025/26.
A 76% mark-up means R176 charged for every R100 of supply cost. Of each rand billed, about 43c sat above the cost. These are our sums, and they apply to the business customers in the case, not to households.
Judge RG Tolmay said she wants an order that gives real relief and stops users returning to court over wrong tariffs. “This cannot go on indefinitely,” she said, according to Moneyweb. She raised an independent expert to work out the overcharging, and stricter court supervision of the order. The lawyers have been told to bring proposals.
Source: Cost of R100 is our own base. The 76% mark-up is from the court hearing as reported by Moneyweb, Daily Maverick and The Citizen. Chart: Rand Desk
The dispute over refunds
The applicants want credits on their accounts, with interest if repayment is delayed, or temporary tariffs while NERSA recalculates, according to Daily Maverick. Mpact proposed limiting any adjustment to the parties before the court. NERSA said that would be unfair to other users and that any adjustment should apply to everyone in the municipalities concerned. It also asked to phase in corrections over future years, the way Eskom’s are.
Ekurhuleni, which has opposed the applications, told the court it cannot afford to refund customers, according to Moneyweb.
Daily Maverick said it sent questions to NERSA and the Nelson Mandela Bay Municipality and had no reply when it published.
An earlier case, and a missed deadline
The Citizen reported that the court has heard of several comparable cases in the past decade. Moneyweb reported an earlier ruling, by Judge Anthony Millar in Pretoria roughly a year back, that NERSA’s 2024/25 approvals for Johannesburg, Ekurhuleni, Madibeng and Msunduzi were unlawful, and in January sent them back to NERSA. The 30 June deadline passed without a new determination, and the work was still open in November, the report said. The order says that a missed deadline puts the previous year’s tariff, or the matching Eskom tariff, in force.
EWN reported that Melanie Veness, chief executive of the Pietermaritzburg and Midlands Chamber of Business, said members are deducting court-ordered credits from their own monthly bills in Msunduzi. The Citizen reported that she put the credits the municipality must grant at about R200 million for nearly 700 businesses, and that this has yet to happen.
Polity reported on 19 November 2025 a ruling in a case brought by AfriForum that found that NERSA’s process for approving 2025/26 municipal tariffs was unconstitutional because of inadequate cost studies and public participation.
How this reaches your bill
A household’s electricity price is a municipal tariff, set within the limit NERSA approves. The 2026/27 increases for Cape Town, Nelson Mandela Bay, Mangaung and Buffalo City are in our metro electricity story, and each metro’s figure is on the electricity tariffs page. How the approval works is in our explainer on NERSA.
The hearing continues, and the court has not yet made an order.