The Hawks arrested a Limpopo legislature member and a company owner over the Giyani water project on 19 November. Both appeared in the Polokwane Magistrate’s Court the next day.

The Special Investigating Unit (SIU) named them as Kennedy Tshivhase, who sits in the legislature and once chaired the board of Lepelle Northern Water (LNW), and Thulani Majola, who owns LTE Consulting and runs it as chief executive. The SIU welcomed the arrests in a statement on Friday. Neither man has been convicted, and the charges are allegations; the reports say nothing of a plea. Another Hawks corruption case is covered in our story on the Tembisa Hospital arrests.

What the SIU and the Hawks allege

The SIU says its probe, run under Proclamation R22 of 2016, turned up evidence that Majola allegedly paid bribes to Tshivhase over the contract. It alleges they were a Mercedes-Benz G63 and R2.7 million moved to the Tshivhase Royal Trust.

The Hawks describe the case differently. Their statement, carried by SAnews, does not name the suspects, but gives their ages as 64 and 51, which match those IOL gave for Tshivhase and Majola. It alleges that the then LNW chairperson appointed a company owned by the second suspect without competitive bidding. The Hawks allege the project was valued at about R90 million at the start and grew to R4.4 billion without the necessary authorisation. They allege the company director gave the chairperson a G63 and paid R500,000 into his personal and business accounts.

The reports disagree on the size of the project and the payments. The SIU calls it a R4.1 billion contract. The Hawks say R4.4 billion. IOL reported that the National Prosecuting Authority (NPA) put the project at R3.2 billion, and that the State alleges R500,000 went into a Tshivhase Investment Holdings account. This story does not choose between those figures.

Court appearance

IOL reported that the two men appeared alongside LTE Consulting, facing corruption and money laundering charges. The NPA alleges Tshivhase abused his position as LNW chairperson to help LTE Consulting win contracts. The case was postponed to 26 November for further investigation and a formal bail application, IOL reported.

The SIU’s civil case and preserved assets

Apart from the arrests, the SIU has gone to the Limpopo Division of the High Court in Polokwane. Its summons asks the court to review and set aside the LTE Consulting contract, because the SIU says it was given out irregularly and unlawfully.

The SIU also listed steps against two former LNW officials. Phineas Legodi, who ran LNW as chief executive, resigned after the SIU referred him for discipline. The SIU says it has preserved his pension benefits and four properties. Carel Schamhl was LNW’s operations general manager until he was dismissed, and the SIU says it has preserved his pension fund, which holds R10.2 million. The SIU said the orders exist so that assets cannot be disposed of while the civil case runs. The reports do not say that Legodi or Schamhl face criminal charges, and they carry no response from either man.

On the sampled boreholes, the SIU said it found an estimated loss of R7,048,712.35 from inflated costs, as quoted by IOL. It also found about R2,503,300 in wasteful spending on water purification plants that do not work. Together that is about R9.55 million, a small fraction of the contract value the SIU is contesting. The statement does not say how many boreholes were sampled.

Background

LNW was appointed in 2014 as implementing agent for a project meant to ease the water crisis in Giyani and nearby villages, according to the Hawks. If the Hawks’ figures are right, the project grew about 49 times from its starting value.

The next step is the Polokwane court on 26 November, where a bail application is expected.