The National Consumer Tribunal has ruled that a Pretoria restaurant may not add a 10% service charge to bills by default. The Citizen, IOL, EWN and Sowetan all reported the decision against TriBeCa Standard on 18, 19 and 20 November.

The ruling follows a tip-off to the National Consumer Commission (NCC). According to The Citizen and IOL, the Commission’s investigation found about 200 service charges processed each day, which IOL said showed the fee was routinely imposed. The menu called the charge discretionary, but it was added to bills anyway, and customers who were unhappy had to tell management.

The NCC’s own quarterly report, dated April 2026, describes the same matter. It says the charge was applied by default, was only brought to a customer’s attention at the point of payment, and that customers had to request its removal.

What the Tribunal found

The Tribunal found two breaches of the Consumer Protection Act, as reported by The Citizen and Sowetan. The first is section 23(6)(a), which bars a supplier from making a consumer pay more than the displayed price. The menu did not say what the extra charge was for, nor show the full price payable.

The second concerns sections 48(1), 51(1)(a)(i) and 51(1)(b)(i). The Tribunal found that making customers challenge the charge when service is poor is unfair, because it indirectly requires them to give up their right to quality service. It declared the restaurant’s conduct prohibited.

Tipping stays lawful. According to IOL, the NCC said “genuine voluntary tips are not prohibited under the CPA. However, a tip must be freely chosen by the consumer and cannot be automatically added to the bill.” The Citizen reported the same wording as the Tribunal’s clarification.

The restaurant’s side and the inspections

EWN reported that TriBeCa Standard cooperated with the Tribunal and told the Tribunal it had stopped adding the charge automatically and had taken the wording off its menu. The reports do not say whether the restaurant was fined or ordered to refund customers.

NCC Acting Commissioner Hardin Ratshisusu welcomed the decision. “This is a significant judgment and should deter other restaurants from the practice,” he said, according to Sowetan. He added that restaurants are reminded that undisclosed charges not shown in menu prices break the Act.

What a customer can do

Knowler told EWN a diner can ask for the fee to be taken off, “and you don’t have to complain about the service to do so”. She said a refusal can be reported to the NCC. The Citizen reported that South Africans have complained on social media in recent months about automatic service fees, and that some want inspections to start in Cape Town.

The NCC said it will carry out nationwide inspections of restaurants. None of the reports gives a start date for them.